14 Incredible Gifts for Broadway Lovers

Looking for the perfect gift for that special thespian in your life? Then make sure to read through this list of our absolute favorite gifts for Broadway lovers – all of which can be purchased online. Happy shopping!

Please note: This post contains affiliate links. This means that if you choose to make a purchase through one of the following links, we may earn a small commission on the sale at no additional cost to you. See our disclosure for more info.

1. Break an Egg: The Broadway Cookbook

Oh my gosh, this is a MUST have for any thespian/foodie. Take a look inside with Amazon’s preview feature and see what types of Broadway-inspired recipes are in there!

Break an Egg Broadway Cookbook.

2. Bullets On Broadway Murder Mystery Game

This gift is interesting because it can be enjoyed virtually with friends, so it’s the perfect option if you aren’t able to spend the holidays with the Broadway lover in your life this year. And it can be played with 4-20 players!

Bullets on Broadway Game.

3. Kurt Adler Glass Broadway Ornament

This is such a classy and timeless ornament that any Broadway lover would get joy out of for years and years to come – the perfect Broadway Christmas gift!

Glass Broadway Ornament.

4. Triple Broadway Playbill Frame

If you’ve ever thought about displaying your Playbill programs on the wall, you know that it’s not easy to find the perfect fitting frame. But this triple frame is made specifically for your Playbill!

Triple Playbill Frame.

5. A Classy Broadway Playbill Binder

As an alternative to Playbill framing, a Broadway Playbill binder is a must for any regular theatre-goer. So if you are thinking about getting this as a gift for someone, just make sure they don’t already have one first. And if they don’t, be prepared for a big hug of “thanks”!

Playbill Binder.

6. “I’d Rather Be at a Broadway Show” Coloring Postcards

Coloring Broadway has so many fun coloring pages, and this one would be the perfect choice for anyone who is obsessed with going to Broadway shows!

Broadway Show Coloring Postcards.

7. “Be a Broadway Star” Board Game

This is a super fun gift for anyone who is dreaming of becoming a star on Broadway. Encourage them to live out their dream with this awesome board game – and play it with them as a little bonus!

Be a Broadway Star.

8. Broadway: A History of NYC in Thirteen Miles

This book tells the whole history of Broadway – it would be a great gift for either a theatre history buff or an avid reader who is in love with NYC!

Broadway A History Book.

9. Broadway: The Musicals – 1000-Piece Puzzle

If you’re looking for a gift that just screams MUSICALS, this is your best bet. This puzzle is jam-packed with classic Broadway musicals, and is best enjoyed when puzzling to your favorite showtunes.

Broadway puzzle.

10. Broadway Musical Trivia Book

Think your loved one is up for a challenge? Put their knowledge to the test with this book of quiz questions – all related to Broadway!

Broadway Musical Trivia Book.

11. Times Square Paint by Number

This year I’ve gotten into painting by number for the first time, and I’m loving it. Each kit will keep you busy for countless hours as they are all super detailed. This would make a very fun and unexpected gift for any Broadway lover!

Times Square Paint by Number.

12. When the Lights Are Bright Again

This is such a beautiful book that captures the emotions of the theatre community during the Covid-19 Pandemic. Inside you’ll find over 200 personal letters written about and during the shut down by a wide variety of thespians.

When the Lights Are Bright Again Book.

13. Broadway Blend K-Cups

If you’re looking for a Broadwayish gift that’s a bit more subtle, this one would be such a clever one for any coffee drinker. And if they have a regular coffee maker, you can get them the regular Broadway Blend beans!

Broadway Blend KCups.

14. The Thespian’s Bucket List

And of course, I can’t leave my own book The Thespian’s Bucket List off of the list! It’s an interactive checklist with 1,001 items that every theatre lover absolutely MUST do and/or experience in their lifetime. This is an especially great gift for Broadway lovers, as you’re also able to track every single show that you’ve seen!

The Thespian's Bucket List.

MORE Amazing Theatre Gift Ideas:

Theatre Jigsaw Puzzles

Musical Theatre Gifts

Gifts for Broadway Lovers → You are here!

Gifts for Singers

Gifts for Theatre Lovers

Hamilton Gifts

Gifts for Actors

Theatre Gifts for Kids

Which of these gifts for Broadway lovers is your favorite?

Or have you ever received any Broadway gifts that you went absolutely crazy for? Feel free to share in the comments below! Here’s wishing you a wonderful holiday season filled with fun and stress-free shopping. Happy holidays!

Want a weekly list of stagey surprises?!

Sign up for Theatre Thursday.

Stacy Karyn, author of Gifts for Actors.
Author: Stacy Karyn

Stacy Karyn is the founder of Theatre Trip, author of The Thespian’s Bucket List, and creator of The Cast Album List. She has a TESOL drama certificate, a BA in theatre, and has worked and interned with Broadway and Off-Broadway theaters.


Leave a Reply

Skip to content