Audition Songs for First Date – By Character
Last Updated: January, 2026
When considering audition songs for First Date, it’s fitting to choose a song from contemporary musical theatre repertoire that aligns with the tone of the show and suits your vocal type. Always refer to the audition notice for specific guidelines.
Because First Date premiered in 2012, the audition songs below are drawn from musicals between the 2000s and 2020s. Each one has been carefully hand-picked and reviewed by a musical theatre professional to ensure fit and audition readiness.
Note: This post contains affiliate links. If you purchase through these links, we may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. For more details, please see our full disclosure.
Step 1: Review Audition Info
Please read your audition details carefully, as they sometimes specify the type of song they’d like to hear (a ballad, something uptempo, etc.). Make sure to select a song that’s appropriate for your specific casting call.
Step 2: Study the Show
Before auditioning, you should get familiar with the show, and listening to the cast album is a great way to do that. Here’s where you can learn more about First Date.
Step 3: Pick an Audition Song
Before choosing a song, find your voice type and range using the Vocal Guide.
Based on your personality and vocal range, decide whether you’d prefer to audition for the ensemble or a specific character. Even if you audition for a specific role, stay open to other casting possibilities.
When you’re ready, choose a song from below that best fits your voice and comfort level.
The Audition Songs
Aaron
“As Good As I Get” – Next Thing You Know
“Isn’t That Enough?” – Honeymoon in Vegas
“Whatever” – It Shoulda Been You
“You Never Know” – If/Then
Casey
“Always Starting Over” – If/Then
“Even Though” – I Love You Because
“Losing Track of Time” – Summer of ’42
“You Can’t Be Everything You Want” – Next Thing You Know
Ensemble (Altos)
“Gotta Get Out” – Ordinary Days
“Just Not Now” – I Love You Because
“Manhattan Bridge” – Next Thing You Know
Ensemble (Baritones)
“Favorite Places” – Ordinary Days
“Goodbye” – I Love You Because
“Morning After Omelet” – Next Thing You Know
Ensemble (Basses)
“Mrs. Remington” – The Story of My Life
“Something About Her” – Pretty Woman
“What Would You Do?” – If/Then
Ensemble (Contras)
“Calm” – Ordinary Days
“Don’t Wanna Be Here” – Ordinary Days
“Let Things Go” – Ordinary Days
Ensemble (Mezzos/Sopranos)
“I Can’t Go Back” – Pretty Woman
“On and On and On” – We Aren’t Kids Anymore
“Remember This” – The Mad Ones
Ensemble (Tenors)
“And I Breathe” – Next Thing You Know
“Nobody Needs to Know” – The Last Five Years
“Run Away With Me” – The Mad Ones
Step 4: Select a Monologue
If requested, here are a few audition monologues for First Date:
• “How to Be Alone” from East Haddam
• “It’s Best” from Elsewhere
• “Personally Speaking” in Audition Arsenal for Men in Their 20s➝
Final Step: Audition Prep
Once you’ve chosen your song, it’s time to start preparing! Grab your FREE Audition Prep Checklist and Stamp Cards to stay organized and motivated for your upcoming auditions!
First Date Song List
Here’s a list of the musical numbers in First Date, along with which characters sing in each of them. Unless you have been asked to, do not choose from the below songs for your audition! The following is more intended to be used for character research purposes.
* That said, if you’ve specifically been asked to sing a song from the show, you can find the sheet music for the best possible audition songs below.
“The One” – Company
“First Impressions” – Aaron, Casey
“Bailout Song #1” – Reggie
“The Girl For You” – Company
“The Awkward Pause” – Company
“Allison’s Theme #1” – Allison
“That’s Why You Love Me” – Ensemble
“Bailout Song #2” – Reggie
“Safer” – Casey
“I’d Order Love” – Waiter
“Allison’s Theme #2” – Aaron, Allison, Gabe
“The Things I Never Said” – Aaron, Aaron’s Mother
“Bailout Song #3” – Reggie
“In Love With You” – Aaron
“The Check!” – Company
“Something That Will Last” – Casey, Aaron, Company
Want more songs? Check out these DIY Rep Books for EVERY vocal type!
Author: Stacy Karyn
Stacy Karyn is the founder of Theatre Trip and the author of The Thespian’s Bucket List. She is also the creator of The Cast Album List. Her background includes a BA in Theatre, a TESOL Drama certificate, and professional experience in Broadway and Off-Broadway theaters.
